AI Is Taking Over College Admissions

May Be Interested In:Trump Is Not the Only Republican Who Fits the Fascist Definition




Society

/

StudentNation


/
October 11, 2024

For many high school students, artificial intelligence only heightens the anxieties around applying to college. How much of their application will be read by a human?

Doctoral student and AI expert Sven Schulze using examples and data to explain the error-proneness of ChatGPT.(Frank Rumpenhorst / Getty)

In 2024, Duke University announced that it would no longer assign a numerical value to undergraduate college admissions essays when scoring an applicant. While the university would still ask students to submit essays, they couldn’t be seen as an accurate reflection of writing ability. “They are not given a numerical rating, but considered as we think holistically about a candidate as a potential member of the Duke community,” Dean of undergraduate admissions Christoph Guttentag told the Duke Chronicle.

The personal-essay component of the college application has long served as a method to better understand a student’s interests, desires and motivations beyond their quantifiable achievements, and was “valuable in helping to identify competitive applicants,” according to Guttentag. But generative artificial intelligence has diminished the value of these essays. “It’s the fastest growth that we’ve seen of any platform and any kind of new technology and AI is not slowing down,” explains Dr. Asim Ali, the executive director of Teaching and Learning Innovation at Auburn University.

Over the last year, an increasing number of students have begun using platforms like ChatGPT and Caktus.ai to help complete their classwork. A recent survey found that ChatGPT was landing more and more high school kids in the principal’s office for plagiarism and academic dishonesty. But the same pattern has emerged in college admissions—allowing applicants to subcontract the writing process.

“It accelerates everything, but it doesn’t necessarily give depth to the learning. It’s taking away from kids’ learning. They’ve got to learn how to write. They’ve got to learn history,” said Catherine Marrs, a college admissions counselor based in North Texas. “The trend that I’m seeing is that kids are less and less ready to go to college.”

A survey done by Inside Higher Ed in September 2023 reported that eight in 10 colleges would use AI in admissions for the 2024 cycle. The same survey found that 70 percent of admissions officers saw AI being used to review recommendation letters and transcripts, with 60 percent saying that it was used to review personal essays. The report was met with skepticism by admissions officer Liam Borst, vice provost for enrollment management at UGA, who posted on X, “There is a zero percent chance admissions offices are using AI to read files.” Yet students are increasingly concerned with how AI can affect their applications.

“It would be hypocritical on the colleges’ hand to prohibit the use of AI for their students when they are using AI,” says Nicholas Segesmen, a high school sophomore from Coronado High School in El Paso Texas. “Admissions offices’ using AI graders feels unfair and impersonal,” said Husam Ramadan, a high school junior at Clovis North High School in Fresno, California. “With so much riding on these essays, I’d want them judged by a human who can comprehend nuance and depth.”

Current Issue

Cover of October 2024 Issue

As a high school student, it sometimes feels like college admissions have taken over my life. But the involvement of AI only increases my anxieties: How much of my application will be read by a human?

Generative artificial intelligence has infiltrated every aspect of the application process—including the role of teachers, as more and more educators are reportedly using AI to write student recommendations. These letters are used to understand how students work and interact with their peers and instructors, and while these programs allow teachers to produce recommendations faster, the quality suffers. “These letters are supposed to allow admissions officers to get another accredited individual’s opinion on you as a person,” said Miranda Li, a high school junior at Sylvania Northview High School in Sylvania Ohio. “AI cannot possibly replicate the connection and the familiarity of a genuine letter of recommendation.”

Realistically though, some teachers feel that using generative AI to get a basic structure and building upon it allows the letter to be both genuine and efficient. “I go to ChatGPT, but then I don’t put that directly, because I know these kids better than ChatGPT ever will, right? I go through and I change things around. I make it so that there might be overlaps in the letters, but every letter is going to have something personal,” said Pedro Delgado, a computer science teacher at Young Women’s STEAM Academy in El Paso, Texas.

The recent shifts within admissions offices have students changing strategies during the application process. “I’ve realized I need to be even more diligent about clearly demonstrating my authentic abilities,” said Ramadan. “In-person interviews have become higher priorities for showcasing my knowledge rather than just papers an AI could hypothetically assist with.”

“Students have to make the choice not to use AI,” said admissions counselor Bob Carlton from College Matchpoint. “They have to make a choice that their voice can beat the bot. That they can be better than a classmate who might choose to use AI.” Using AI for essays often leads to poorly written, formulaic, and cliché essay structures that aren’t personable or attractive to admissions offices. “Writing the essay yourself, while it may be time-consuming, gives you the time and the power to write an essay that will blow the college admissions officers away,” said Li.

“We know that we have some kids that are utilizing it. We also have to keep academic integrity, and we have had some students in the past jeopardize their opportunities because they’re using AI incorrectly,” said Caitlyn Stillwell, college counselor for North Star Academy in Newark, New Jersey.

Although detection systems like Persona and Phasely.Ai claim to find text that is generated by an AI writing tool, they are still far from entirely accurate. Faults within detection systems and the increasing concern of admissions officers about the usage of AI leave high school students worried that their essays could also be falsely classified as AI-generated.

“Admissions officers are more weary than ever,” said Amelia Ramirez, a high school sophomore from New York. “That translates into students who value sincerity. The worry is that AI detectors may detect a student’s work to be loaded with AI when it was truthfully written by hand. It is a worry my peers have expressed, and something I’ve seen others fall victim to online.”

“If you’re going to pass a rule that says don’t use generative AI, there’s no way to enforce that. So then it becomes a way of creating a disadvantage for honest people,” said Dr. Ali. “So I think the alternative is to change the way we do the admissions process. If it uses an essay, we’ve got to get more creative.”

Without changes like the refinement of the essay at Duke University or mandatory additions to the application process—like interviews and spoken recommendations that make the admissions process more holistic—honest students will suffer. And without clear guidelines that acknowledge AI usage and explain how and when to use it correctly, the admissions process becomes more taxing for all students. “One of the top five stressors for kids is the college admissions process,” said Carlton. “AI for many kids and parents, just introduces another area of uncertainty, another area of fear.”

Can we count on you?

In the coming election, the fate of our democracy and fundamental civil rights are on the ballot. The conservative architects of Project 2025 are scheming to institutionalize Donald Trump’s authoritarian vision across all levels of government if he should win.

We’ve already seen events that fill us with both dread and cautious optimism—throughout it all, The Nation has been a bulwark against misinformation and an advocate for bold, principled perspectives. Our dedicated writers have sat down with Kamala Harris and Bernie Sanders for interviews, unpacked the shallow right-wing populist appeals of J.D. Vance, and debated the pathway for a Democratic victory in November.

Stories like these and the one you just read are vital at this critical juncture in our country’s history. Now more than ever, we need clear-eyed and deeply reported independent journalism to make sense of the headlines and sort fact from fiction. Donate today and join our 160-year legacy of speaking truth to power and uplifting the voices of grassroots advocates.

Throughout 2024 and what is likely the defining election of our lifetimes, we need your support to continue publishing the insightful journalism you rely on.

Thank you,
The Editors of The Nation

Marium Zahra

Marium Zahra is a high school student and writer from El Paso, Texas.

More from The Nation

A student uses their cell phone after unlocking the pouch that secures it from use during the school day at Bayside Academy in California.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul has considered a statewide ban on smart devices in schools, but many parents, students, and teachers have a more nuanced view.

StudentNation

/

Ushoshi Das

A sea of Palestinian flags waved by fans in the stands of the UEFA Champions League football match between Borussia Dortmund and Celtic in Dortmund, western Germany on October 1, 2024.

FIFA banned apartheid South Africa. It banned Russia for invading Ukraine. But about Israel, FIFA does nothing.

Jules Boykoff and Dave Zirin

What Kind of Damage Will the Supreme Court Inflict This Term?

To understand the ambitions of the conservative majority, look no farther than Project 2025, which was cooked up by some of the same people who engineered the current court.

Feature

/

Elie Mystal

Stanford University President Jonathan Levin.

Why are places like Stanford and Johns Hopkins hosting gatherings of well-known coronavirus cranks?

Gregg Gonsalves

Pete Rose holding a baseball mitt in position during a Cincinnati Reds game.

The baseball legend was an example of not only the perils of gambling but also why the sports leagues’ embrace of the online-betting industry makes them predatory hypocrites.

Obituary

/

Dave Zirin

Sen. J.D. Vance onstage at a rally, surrounded by Trump/Vance signs.

Not only are abortion bans actively harmful to women and their families—they also don’t work to recreate the past as conservatives want them to.

Elizabeth Gregory




share Share facebook pinterest whatsapp x print

Similar Content

House Judiciary Committee links Democratic policies to increased crime
House Judiciary Committee links Democratic policies to increased crime
Israel Invaded Lebanon Because the United States Let It
Israel Invaded Lebanon Because the United States Let It
Tester, Sheehy clash in final debate with Montana Senate seat up for grabs
Tester, Sheehy clash in final debate with Montana Senate seat up for grabs
In Lebanon, Israel Is Only Sowing the Seeds of More Bloodshed and Terror
In Lebanon, Israel Is Only Sowing the Seeds of More Bloodshed and Terror
Georgia judge blocks state's ballot hand counting rule
Georgia judge blocks state's ballot hand counting rule
Jock the monkey listens in on the Scopes trial, 1923.
The Scopes Trial and the Two Visions of US Democracy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Global Pulse: Stay Ahead of the Curve | © 2024 | Daily News